When did care become currency?

1Twelve people at a table, most of them vaguely successful, all of whom will mention at least once before the salad arrives the ways in which they stay busy. The conversation is good, even warm. Someone brings up a book. Someone else knows the author personally. The evening has the texture of friendship. And then, driving home afterward, you feel it: a faint but precise dissatisfaction that you cannot name. Not loneliness, exactly. Something more specific. The sense that everyone at that table, including you, was performing a transaction you had all agreed, without words, to call a friendship.

What the market did Neoliberalism and human relationships have become deeply intertwined as economic structures reshaped how people relate to one another by making the market the dominant model for every exchange, including exchanges that had previously operated on an entirely different logic. In market logic, things have value because they can be traded. Time has value because it can be sold. Attention has value because it can be monetised. Relationships, by extension, become portfolios: assets you cultivate because they might yield returns, or liabilities you quietly divest from when they stop paying out.3 What is less commonly noticed is the particular cognitive mechanism through which it operates. A series of studies by Fitzsimons and Shah found that when people are actively pursuing a personal goal, they unconsciously bring to mind the individuals who are useful for achieving it, evaluating those people more positively, drawing closer to them, and approaching them more readily than others who are equally present in their lives but not instrumentally useful [1]. What makes this finding strange and unsettling is that none of it happens on purpose. The participants did not decide to rank their friends by utility. The instrumental sorting happened automatically, beneath conscious awareness, because the mind had absorbed the logic of optimisation so thoroughly that it applied it even to love.The same research found something else: once the goal was achieved, closeness to the instrumental person declined [1]. The friend who helped you get the job, the contact who connected you to the right investor, the colleague who vouched for you at the moment it mattered most. Afterward, there is always a small, almost imperceptible cooling.

The weight of keeping score
2
It helps to understand what care actually requires: what it demands. The capacity to be genuinely present with another person, to care about their experience without calculating what it might yield, is not a moral achievement so much as a neurological one. It requires something researchers call mentalising: the ability to hold the inner world of another person in mind as real and complex and separate from your own needs [2]. This is metabolically expensive. It takes attention, which is finite. And when attention is organised primarily around self-optimisation, around the question of what this interaction is for, the capacity for genuine mentalising shrinks.The result is not that people become efficient. They respond to distress in ways that are technically supportive but tonally managed. They make time for you when it is convenient, which is to say they are present without being there. And slowly, over years of interactions structured this way, a particular kind of trust becomes harder to build: the trust that someone would show up for you not because it benefits them but because they are the kind of person who shows up.When relationships are valued primarily for their instrumental usefulness, a form of dehumanisation occurs in which one denies the full humanity of a social target while using them to achieve self-interested goals [3]. But this language makes it sound intentional, which it rarely is. Most people who treat their friends this way believe, genuinely, that they care about them. A brief interlude on the city, and what it asks

There is a version of this that is architectural. Indian cities are places where the middle distance is full of strangers who are also, something like community: the family in the flat above, the autorickshaw driver who knows your usual route, the chaiwala near the office who remembers you take no sugar. For generations, these encounters had a kind of thickness to them. They were not friendships, exactly, but they were not transactions either. They existed in a register that the market has replaced.

The apartment complexes that replaced the older neighborhoods are designed around amenity and security, not encounters. You can live for five years in a high-rise and never learn the name of the person whose bathroom shares a wall with yours. The gym is on the fourth floor. The WhatsApp group for residents exists primarily to complain about parking. The architecture is optimised for privacy, which turns out to be another word, in this context, for isolation.

What the city asks of you now is not neighborliness. It asks for legibility. You are welcome in proportion to how clearly you can signal your category: your income bracket, your cultural literacy and your professional tier.

The epidemiology of care

The public health dimensions of this are not speculative. In 2023, the US Surgeon General declared loneliness and social isolation a public health crisis, noting that insufficient social connection carries a health risk comparable to smoking fifteen cigarettes a day [4]. The United Kingdom appointed a Minister for Loneliness in 2018, Japan followed in 2021 and South Korea began offering monthly stipends to encourage socially isolated young people to reintegrate into society [5].

But the public health framing misses something important about causation. It treats loneliness as the problem, when loneliness may be the symptom of something more structural. Neoliberal ideology promotes individualism and self-interest in ways that diminish wellbeing, prompting individuals to prioritise personal gain over genuinely humane connection with others [3]. The loneliness epidemic is not primarily a failure of social skills or digital distraction. It is what happens when the organising logic of a society trains people to evaluate relationships by their return on investment.

The irony is that the market solution to loneliness is more market. Therapy apps. Wellness retreats. Social skills coaching. Friendship-formation platforms. The same ideological system that commodified connection now sells products designed to address the relational poverty it produced [3].

What we owe each other, and the invoice
4

There is a specific conversation that many couples in their thirties have had, or are perpetually on the edge of having, that did not exist in quite the same form a generation ago. It is not about money, or children, or whose turn it is to call the plumber. It is about emotional labour: who is carrying more of the invisible weight of the relationship, who is doing the remembering and the planning and the noticing, and whether this distribution is fair. The language of fairness, of equal distribution, of who is doing more and the accounting logic of a workplace have been imported into the most intimate space two people can share.

The concept of emotional labor was introduced by the sociologist Arlie Hochschild in 1983 to describe the work of managing one's feelings as a professional requirement, such as that seen in the flight attendant trained to smile regardless of what she feels [6]. Hochschild's framework was later extended to domestic life, particularly by feminist scholars examining the unpaid work women perform inside heterosexual partnerships. This extension was necessary and correct. The problem is what happened next: the concept migrated from critique into lifestyle. People began auditing their relationships the way they audit their time.

Research on the fairness heuristic in close relationships finds that perceived inequity is one of the strongest predictors of relationship dissatisfaction and that people are acutely, sometimes hyperactively, sensitive to imbalance vis-a-vis what they give versus what they receive [7]. In a culture that has trained people to treat their time and energy as scarce capital, of course they track where it goes. They notice when the returns feel insufficient. The problem is that a relationship governed primarily by fairness is not love. It is a contract. And contracts, unlike love, have exit clauses.

When you are inside a relationship that is running on equity logic, you feel it as a low-level vigilance that never fully switches off. And this vigilance forecloses something that intimacy actually requires, which is the willingness to be temporarily, ungrudgingly in deficit. To give more than you are getting, for a season, because the person you love needs it and you are the person who can provide it. The word for this used to be devotion. Today it has become a source of anxiety and resentment, because devotion without reciprocity looks, in market terms, like a bad investment.

What is rarely said is that relationships which survive over decades survive partly because both people are, at different moments, willing to be unprofitable. Illness, failure, depression, grief: these are seasons in which one person necessarily carries more, and the relationship holds not because of a renegotiated contract but because of something that precedes and exceeds calculation.
What social exchange theory got right, and what it missed
Social exchange theory, the dominant academic framework for understanding relationships for the last sixty years, argues that human beings are fundamentally rational actors in their social lives: they evaluate relationships through cost-benefit analysis, remain in relationships that yield more reward than cost and exit those that don't. The theory holds that social relationships function like economic exchanges in which each person controls things the other values and decides whether to continue based on how beneficial and fair the exchange feels over time [8]. 

5
Social exchange theory was developed by Peter Blau and George Homans in the 1950s and 60s, drawing on both behaviorism and economics [8]. Core social exchange theory criticism points out that the framework views motives and outcomes of social behavior as purely rational and treats actors as essentially emotionless; while it acknowledges the role of emotions in certain aspects of behavior, it fails to theorise about them effectively [9]. The framework cannot account for the way people love inconveniently.What has happened since Blau wrote is not that his theory became more true. What happened is that people were trained, through decades of labor flexibility, self-branding, gig work and the relentless productivity rhetoric of late capitalism, to behave as if his theory were the whole picture. The descriptive became prescriptive.
The cost nobody is accounting for
6
From the inside it feels like checking. A low-grade, nearly automatic audit of whether the people around you are serving your life goals. In a practical way that you might check whether a subscription is still worth keeping. And then, occasionally, with a shock of shame, catching yourself doing it with someone you love.

The shame matters. It means something has not been fully colonised. It means part of you remembers a different accounting system, one in which the value of being with another person was not separable from the experience of being with them, and in which a friendship could be meaningful without being useful.

But the shame passes, because you are busy and because the environment keeps reinforcing the instrumental frame. The language of business infiltrates the language of love so gradually that you stop noticing it, until someone you barely know describes their marriage as a "partnership" and you realise you cannot remember the last time you heard someone describe it as something harder to name.

What the frameworks miss

The research can tell you that goal-instrumentality shapes relationship evaluations [1], that loneliness damages coronary health [4] and that neoliberal ideology correlates with dehumanising social behavior [3]. What it cannot tell you is what happens in the body when you are cared for without conditions. The particular quality of attention that arrives when someone sits with you not because it benefits them, but simply because they like the specific person that you are.

This experience is becoming rare enough that many people in their thirties and forties struggle to recognise it when it happens. They assume, because the market has taught them to assume, that there must be an exchange they haven't identified yet. Sometimes they are right. Sometimes they are not, and their inability to simply receive the care is itself a kind of loss.


Intimacy requires a willingness to be unprofitable. To be a burden sometimes and to let others be a burden to you, not because the burden will eventually be reciprocated but because bearing it is what love means. The market does not have a category for this. And so it quietly becomes, in many lives, less and less available.

Somewhere between late adolescence and thirty, most people learn to manage their relationships the way they manage their inboxes. Strategically. With triage. The urgent ones get attended to; the others stay marked unread until they drop off the screen. This emerged from the same logic that produced the gig economy and the personal brand: the logic that every resource, including time and attention, must be allocated with maximum efficiency.

The people who maintain friendships that are genuinely without utility, who call when there is nothing to gain and show up when it is inconvenient, seem to be practicing something almost countercultural. Something quietly radical.

What would it mean if the most subversive thing a person could do was to be a bad return on investment? To take up space in someone's life without offering anything immediately useful in return? To be loved, and love back, in the old extravagant way that markets cannot process and ledgers cannot hold?

The question is not rhetorical. Something in the body knows the answer. The problem is whether we have retained enough silence, enough slowness, enough refusal of the audit, to hear it.

References:

[1] Fitzsimons GM, Shah JY. How goal instrumentality shapes relationship evaluations. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2008;95(2):319–37. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.95.2.319

[2] Bateman A, Fonagy P. Mentalization-based treatment. Psychoanal Inq. 2013;33(6):595–613. https://doi.org/10.1080/07351690.2013.835643

[3] van Bremen N, Natrajan-Tyagi R. Humanizing clients with internalized neoliberal ideology using contextual therapy. Fam Process. 2025;64(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/famp.70007

[4] Murthy VH. Our epidemic of loneliness and isolation: the US Surgeon General's advisory on the healing effects of social connection and community. US Department of Health and Human Services; 2023. Available from: https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/surgeon-general-social-connection-advisory.pdf

[5] Bzdok D, Dunbar RIM. Social connection as a critical factor for mental and physical health: evidence, trends, challenges, and future implications. Proc R Soc B. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2024.0892

[6] Hochschild AR. The managed heart: commercialization of human feeling. University of California Press; 1983. ISBN: 9780520272941

[7] Sprecher S. Social exchange theories and sexuality. J Sex Res. 1998;35(1):32–43. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499809551915

[8] Cropanzano R, Mitchell MS. Social exchange theory: an interdisciplinary review. J Manage. 2005;31(6):874–900. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206305279602

[9] Lawler EJ. An affect theory of social exchange. Am J Sociol. 2001;107(2):321–52. https://doi.org/10.1086/324071

When did care become currency?

1Twelve people at a table, most of them vaguely successful, all of whom will mention at least once before the salad arrives the ways in which they stay busy. The conversation is good, even warm. Someone brings up a book. Someone else knows the author personally. The evening has the texture of friendship. And then, driving home afterward, you feel it: a faint but precise dissatisfaction that you cannot name. Not loneliness, exactly. Something more specific. The sense that everyone at that table, including you, was performing a transaction you had all agreed, without words, to call a friendship.

What the market did Neoliberalism and human relationships have become deeply intertwined as economic structures reshaped how people relate to one another by making the market the dominant model for every exchange, including exchanges that had previously operated on an entirely different logic. In market logic, things have value because they can be traded. Time has value because it can be sold. Attention has value because it can be monetised. Relationships, by extension, become portfolios: assets you cultivate because they might yield returns, or liabilities you quietly divest from when they stop paying out.3 What is less commonly noticed is the particular cognitive mechanism through which it operates. A series of studies by Fitzsimons and Shah found that when people are actively pursuing a personal goal, they unconsciously bring to mind the individuals who are useful for achieving it, evaluating those people more positively, drawing closer to them, and approaching them more readily than others who are equally present in their lives but not instrumentally useful [1]. What makes this finding strange and unsettling is that none of it happens on purpose. The participants did not decide to rank their friends by utility. The instrumental sorting happened automatically, beneath conscious awareness, because the mind had absorbed the logic of optimisation so thoroughly that it applied it even to love.The same research found something else: once the goal was achieved, closeness to the instrumental person declined [1]. The friend who helped you get the job, the contact who connected you to the right investor, the colleague who vouched for you at the moment it mattered most. Afterward, there is always a small, almost imperceptible cooling.

The weight of keeping score
2
It helps to understand what care actually requires: what it demands. The capacity to be genuinely present with another person, to care about their experience without calculating what it might yield, is not a moral achievement so much as a neurological one. It requires something researchers call mentalising: the ability to hold the inner world of another person in mind as real and complex and separate from your own needs [2]. This is metabolically expensive. It takes attention, which is finite. And when attention is organised primarily around self-optimisation, around the question of what this interaction is for, the capacity for genuine mentalising shrinks.The result is not that people become efficient. They respond to distress in ways that are technically supportive but tonally managed. They make time for you when it is convenient, which is to say they are present without being there. And slowly, over years of interactions structured this way, a particular kind of trust becomes harder to build: the trust that someone would show up for you not because it benefits them but because they are the kind of person who shows up.When relationships are valued primarily for their instrumental usefulness, a form of dehumanisation occurs in which one denies the full humanity of a social target while using them to achieve self-interested goals [3]. But this language makes it sound intentional, which it rarely is. Most people who treat their friends this way believe, genuinely, that they care about them. A brief interlude on the city, and what it asks

There is a version of this that is architectural. Indian cities are places where the middle distance is full of strangers who are also, something like community: the family in the flat above, the autorickshaw driver who knows your usual route, the chaiwala near the office who remembers you take no sugar. For generations, these encounters had a kind of thickness to them. They were not friendships, exactly, but they were not transactions either. They existed in a register that the market has replaced.

The apartment complexes that replaced the older neighborhoods are designed around amenity and security, not encounters. You can live for five years in a high-rise and never learn the name of the person whose bathroom shares a wall with yours. The gym is on the fourth floor. The WhatsApp group for residents exists primarily to complain about parking. The architecture is optimised for privacy, which turns out to be another word, in this context, for isolation.

What the city asks of you now is not neighborliness. It asks for legibility. You are welcome in proportion to how clearly you can signal your category: your income bracket, your cultural literacy and your professional tier.

The epidemiology of care

The public health dimensions of this are not speculative. In 2023, the US Surgeon General declared loneliness and social isolation a public health crisis, noting that insufficient social connection carries a health risk comparable to smoking fifteen cigarettes a day [4]. The United Kingdom appointed a Minister for Loneliness in 2018, Japan followed in 2021 and South Korea began offering monthly stipends to encourage socially isolated young people to reintegrate into society [5].

But the public health framing misses something important about causation. It treats loneliness as the problem, when loneliness may be the symptom of something more structural. Neoliberal ideology promotes individualism and self-interest in ways that diminish wellbeing, prompting individuals to prioritise personal gain over genuinely humane connection with others [3]. The loneliness epidemic is not primarily a failure of social skills or digital distraction. It is what happens when the organising logic of a society trains people to evaluate relationships by their return on investment.

The irony is that the market solution to loneliness is more market. Therapy apps. Wellness retreats. Social skills coaching. Friendship-formation platforms. The same ideological system that commodified connection now sells products designed to address the relational poverty it produced [3].

What we owe each other, and the invoice
4

There is a specific conversation that many couples in their thirties have had, or are perpetually on the edge of having, that did not exist in quite the same form a generation ago. It is not about money, or children, or whose turn it is to call the plumber. It is about emotional labour: who is carrying more of the invisible weight of the relationship, who is doing the remembering and the planning and the noticing, and whether this distribution is fair. The language of fairness, of equal distribution, of who is doing more and the accounting logic of a workplace have been imported into the most intimate space two people can share.

The concept of emotional labor was introduced by the sociologist Arlie Hochschild in 1983 to describe the work of managing one's feelings as a professional requirement, such as that seen in the flight attendant trained to smile regardless of what she feels [6]. Hochschild's framework was later extended to domestic life, particularly by feminist scholars examining the unpaid work women perform inside heterosexual partnerships. This extension was necessary and correct. The problem is what happened next: the concept migrated from critique into lifestyle. People began auditing their relationships the way they audit their time.

Research on the fairness heuristic in close relationships finds that perceived inequity is one of the strongest predictors of relationship dissatisfaction and that people are acutely, sometimes hyperactively, sensitive to imbalance vis-a-vis what they give versus what they receive [7]. In a culture that has trained people to treat their time and energy as scarce capital, of course they track where it goes. They notice when the returns feel insufficient. The problem is that a relationship governed primarily by fairness is not love. It is a contract. And contracts, unlike love, have exit clauses.

When you are inside a relationship that is running on equity logic, you feel it as a low-level vigilance that never fully switches off. And this vigilance forecloses something that intimacy actually requires, which is the willingness to be temporarily, ungrudgingly in deficit. To give more than you are getting, for a season, because the person you love needs it and you are the person who can provide it. The word for this used to be devotion. Today it has become a source of anxiety and resentment, because devotion without reciprocity looks, in market terms, like a bad investment.

What is rarely said is that relationships which survive over decades survive partly because both people are, at different moments, willing to be unprofitable. Illness, failure, depression, grief: these are seasons in which one person necessarily carries more, and the relationship holds not because of a renegotiated contract but because of something that precedes and exceeds calculation.
What social exchange theory got right, and what it missed
Social exchange theory, the dominant academic framework for understanding relationships for the last sixty years, argues that human beings are fundamentally rational actors in their social lives: they evaluate relationships through cost-benefit analysis, remain in relationships that yield more reward than cost and exit those that don't. The theory holds that social relationships function like economic exchanges in which each person controls things the other values and decides whether to continue based on how beneficial and fair the exchange feels over time [8]. 

5
Social exchange theory was developed by Peter Blau and George Homans in the 1950s and 60s, drawing on both behaviorism and economics [8]. Core social exchange theory criticism points out that the framework views motives and outcomes of social behavior as purely rational and treats actors as essentially emotionless; while it acknowledges the role of emotions in certain aspects of behavior, it fails to theorise about them effectively [9]. The framework cannot account for the way people love inconveniently.What has happened since Blau wrote is not that his theory became more true. What happened is that people were trained, through decades of labor flexibility, self-branding, gig work and the relentless productivity rhetoric of late capitalism, to behave as if his theory were the whole picture. The descriptive became prescriptive.
The cost nobody is accounting for
6
From the inside it feels like checking. A low-grade, nearly automatic audit of whether the people around you are serving your life goals. In a practical way that you might check whether a subscription is still worth keeping. And then, occasionally, with a shock of shame, catching yourself doing it with someone you love.

The shame matters. It means something has not been fully colonised. It means part of you remembers a different accounting system, one in which the value of being with another person was not separable from the experience of being with them, and in which a friendship could be meaningful without being useful.

But the shame passes, because you are busy and because the environment keeps reinforcing the instrumental frame. The language of business infiltrates the language of love so gradually that you stop noticing it, until someone you barely know describes their marriage as a "partnership" and you realise you cannot remember the last time you heard someone describe it as something harder to name.

What the frameworks miss

The research can tell you that goal-instrumentality shapes relationship evaluations [1], that loneliness damages coronary health [4] and that neoliberal ideology correlates with dehumanising social behavior [3]. What it cannot tell you is what happens in the body when you are cared for without conditions. The particular quality of attention that arrives when someone sits with you not because it benefits them, but simply because they like the specific person that you are.

This experience is becoming rare enough that many people in their thirties and forties struggle to recognise it when it happens. They assume, because the market has taught them to assume, that there must be an exchange they haven't identified yet. Sometimes they are right. Sometimes they are not, and their inability to simply receive the care is itself a kind of loss.


Intimacy requires a willingness to be unprofitable. To be a burden sometimes and to let others be a burden to you, not because the burden will eventually be reciprocated but because bearing it is what love means. The market does not have a category for this. And so it quietly becomes, in many lives, less and less available.

Somewhere between late adolescence and thirty, most people learn to manage their relationships the way they manage their inboxes. Strategically. With triage. The urgent ones get attended to; the others stay marked unread until they drop off the screen. This emerged from the same logic that produced the gig economy and the personal brand: the logic that every resource, including time and attention, must be allocated with maximum efficiency.

The people who maintain friendships that are genuinely without utility, who call when there is nothing to gain and show up when it is inconvenient, seem to be practicing something almost countercultural. Something quietly radical.

What would it mean if the most subversive thing a person could do was to be a bad return on investment? To take up space in someone's life without offering anything immediately useful in return? To be loved, and love back, in the old extravagant way that markets cannot process and ledgers cannot hold?

The question is not rhetorical. Something in the body knows the answer. The problem is whether we have retained enough silence, enough slowness, enough refusal of the audit, to hear it.

References:

[1] Fitzsimons GM, Shah JY. How goal instrumentality shapes relationship evaluations. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2008;95(2):319–37. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.95.2.319

[2] Bateman A, Fonagy P. Mentalization-based treatment. Psychoanal Inq. 2013;33(6):595–613. https://doi.org/10.1080/07351690.2013.835643

[3] van Bremen N, Natrajan-Tyagi R. Humanizing clients with internalized neoliberal ideology using contextual therapy. Fam Process. 2025;64(1). https://doi.org/10.1111/famp.70007

[4] Murthy VH. Our epidemic of loneliness and isolation: the US Surgeon General's advisory on the healing effects of social connection and community. US Department of Health and Human Services; 2023. Available from: https://www.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/surgeon-general-social-connection-advisory.pdf

[5] Bzdok D, Dunbar RIM. Social connection as a critical factor for mental and physical health: evidence, trends, challenges, and future implications. Proc R Soc B. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2024.0892

[6] Hochschild AR. The managed heart: commercialization of human feeling. University of California Press; 1983. ISBN: 9780520272941

[7] Sprecher S. Social exchange theories and sexuality. J Sex Res. 1998;35(1):32–43. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499809551915

[8] Cropanzano R, Mitchell MS. Social exchange theory: an interdisciplinary review. J Manage. 2005;31(6):874–900. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206305279602

[9] Lawler EJ. An affect theory of social exchange. Am J Sociol. 2001;107(2):321–52. https://doi.org/10.1086/324071